atism and the whole power of the State sought to crush this movement by assimilating it to the actions and plans of its tiny nihilist minority, there were tens of thousands who came to its defence. Conservatism, by over-reaching itself, succeeded in doing what nihilism was unable to do - to convert criminality into the class war; for what radical spirit could resist the cry from the depths of a movement whose members sang as if they meant it:
When the Union's inspiration through the workers 'blood shall run, There can be no power greater anywhere beneath the sun. Yet what force on earth is weaker than the feeble strength of one? But the Union makes us strong. p> Is there aught we hold in common with the greedy parasite Who would lash us into serfdom and would crush us with his might? Is there anything left for us but to organise and fight? For the Union makes us strong. p> They have taken untold millions that have never toiled to earn But without our brain and muscle not a single wheel can turn, We can break their haughty power, gain our freedom when we learn That the Union makes us strong.
In our hands is placed a power greater than their hoarded gold, Greater than the might of armies magnified a thousand fold, We can bring to birth the new world from the ashes of the old, For the Union makes us strong.
В
Notes:
В
1. The ingredients were common enough in the bush: phosphorus was used for poisoning rabbits, and carbon bi-sulphide in tanning hides. As evidence that the tactic of incendiarism was not unknown in the bush, compare this couplet from a bushranger ballad of the 1880s: "If poor Dan Morgan is cold in the clay, He has two friends called Bryant and May "; and this description of "The present social system of pastoral Australia", from Joseph Furphy's Rigby's Romance : "a patriarchal despotism, tempered by Bryant and May ".
2. There is some-though not very satisfactory-evidence for this. Demanding an inquiry in Parliament in July 1918, TD Mulch said: "The trials were hurried on; and I ask that the Royal Commission shall ... ferret out the telegrams which passed between the State Crown Law Department and the Federal Attorney-General's Department with a view to bringing on these trials at an earlier period than would otherwise be the case. ... we want produced the telegram that Mr Hughes sent, and the telegram which, I understand, the Attorney-General sent. "The Attorney-General denied any such exchange. Mutch retorted: "I have it on the authority of a man who is in a public office. ... I am informed that telegrams did pass between Sydney and Melbourne. "
And Davis Goldstein, in his statutory declaration of July 18, 1918, said that, when he had expressed doubts about the wisdom of the projected raid on the IWW headquarters on September 23, 1916, "Turbet ... replied that instructions, coupled with requests from Melbourne, were to the effect that the raid was to take place immediately and that "something must be done".
I did not discover any such exchanges or instructions in the New South Wales files I examined; this, however, does not prove conclusively that no exchanges took place. Goldstein denied that Turbet had told him about any instructions coming from the Commonwealth Government; however Mr Boyce, Goldstein's counsel, recalled that at one conference - probably on September 25 - Goldstein had complained "that the police bad acted too quickly; that if they could have waited a little longer they would have bagged the lot ".
The Prime Minister's interest might perhaps be established by an entry in Detective Leary's diary for October 1: "Interviewing the Prime Minister who was desirous of communicating with the Inspector-General of Police ". Leary said in evidence that his visit to the Prime Minister had nothing to do with the IWW case - but it was recorded in his notebook in the middle of the pages dealing with the case.
3. The fact that the first mention of the name "Andrew" seems to have appeared in some of the detectives 'diaries a couple of days before this does not necessarily invalidate the suggestion - all the detectives agreed that they often wrote up their diaries days after the event. On the other hand, "Andrew" was first mentioned in Fergusson's diary on this day.
4. Besant was suspected of participation in the forgeries. Perhaps he was picked up because the police had been unable to make this stick.
5. This could have been done by Davis Goldstein, Tom Pope, or one of the police. p> 6. This could have been done by Tom Pope or one of the police. (I should make it clear that I am not accusing Pope of framing Teen or Fagin; I am merely stating that, on the face of the evidence, it was a possibility which bore investigation. To the contrary, Pope's demeanour before Mr Justice Street was that of a genuine members of...
