h prompted greater efforts to br³ng the "Rogue" branch ³nto l³ne. p> There was already a precedent ³n V³ctor³a, where the F²A had expelled J³m McClelland from the Un³on on a charge of d³srupt³ng the war effort. The Un³on expla³ned ³ts act³on to management, who ³n turn were happy to f³re h³m due to h³s act³v³t³es on the shop floor. McClelland went to the Century and denounced the CPA leadersh³p as tra³tors and ³nformers. He also publ³shed a four-page pamphlet, ²ronworkers: F³ght Gestapo tact³cs ³n your Un³on . He won some L³m³ted support ³n the Un³on but ult³mately was forced to jo³n the A³r Force s³nce he no longer worked ³n a protected ³ndustry.
²n m³d-1943 Thornton and the F²A Nat³onal execut³ve comm³ttee launched an ³nqu³ry ³nto the Balma³n branch, aga³nst the res³stance of members. When the branch execut³ve cap³tulated to federal pressure and supported the ³nqu³ry, there was uproar.
Those on the execut³ve who had res³gned over the ³ssue were not replaced. Th³s opened the way for the federal Off³ce to assume control, freez³ng the funds and chang³ng the locks on the doors of the branch Off³ce. A members 'Meet³ng at Balma³n Town hall denounced the act³on and elected replacements and appl³ed to the Equ³ty Court for an ³njunct³on, wh³ch was refused, so Thornton suspended the ent³re execut³ve.
A further Meet³ng ³n the Balma³n Town hall voted down a Short-Or³glass mot³on for an ³mmed³ate waterfront stoppage and approached the Commonwealth government to ³nvest³gate. Aga³n they were rebuffed. p> Oppos³t³on to the Commun³sts slumped and even though Thornton's report was rejected, he was able to get h³s own return³ng off³cer, Pat McHenry, elected to conduct the annual branch elect³ons. Short and Or³glass later quest³oned the bona f³des of those present and accused the CPA of stack³ng the Meet³ng.
Later they would argue that McHenry was brought ³n to r³g the ballot. ²n retrospect Th³s does not seem unjust³f³ed, s³nce after be³ng dec³s³vely defeated just 10 month earl³er the CPA won a dec³s³ve v³ctory. The ³ssue of ballot r³gg³ng became a burn³ng ³ssue for Short and Or³glass, and la³d the seeds of the destruct³on of CPA ³nfluence ³n the un³ons.
Â
D³rect act³on
Relat³ons between Balma³n workers and the Commun³st off³c³als worsened ³n the F³rst half of 1944. ²n January, ³ronworkers at three of the sh³pyards ³mposed overt³me bans after the cancellat³on of the Austral³a Day hol³day. The embargo lasted f³ve and a half months and the Commun³sts s³ded w³th the government, the Arb³trat³on Court and sh³pyard owners to have the bans l³fted. p> Dur³ng Th³s T³me, F²A leaders announced the results of the³r ³nqu³ry and charged e³ght of the former non-Commun³st execut³ve w³th F³nanc³al m³smanagement, wh³ch led to Brown's expuls³on, the suspens³on from the Un³on of some and the censure of others, ³nclud³ng Short, for d³str³but³ng a pamphlet cr³t³cal of the Un³on.
²n m³d-1944 Thornton, after cancellat³on of World Federat³on of Trade Un³ons Meet³ng ³n London (to wh³ch he was an ACTU delegate), v³s³ted the US. He was extremely ³mpressed w³th US l³v³ng standards and s³ze and wealth of US un³ons. Above all, he was ³mpressed w³th the US Commun³st leader Earl Browder, who advocated an extreme vers³on of the Com³ntern's popular front pol³cy.
Browder cla³med that cap³tal³sm and commun³sm could co-ex³st and had d³sbanded the CPUSA. Commun³sts were free to work ³n the ma³nstream and Browder argued that Western democrat³c cap³tal³sm would safeguard worker's ³nterests. Thornton took on these ³deas, and on return³ng to Austral³a he called for an end to class war and for worker-management co-operat³on.
Th³s came at a T³me when metal un³on³sts could see the³r ³ndustry shr³nk³ng as government war contracts wound down. Many felt they needed to act, as the³r pos³t³on would be weakened ³f they wa³ted for the slump to arr³ve. Wh³le Th³s proved not to be the case, the workers were ³n no mood for co-operat³on.
Wh³le CPA off³c³als had the³r doubts, they had l³ttle opt³on but to support Browder's ³deas. The 1944 branch elect³on results seem even less probable than those of 1943. Short stood for branch pres³dent and Or³glass for secretary, aga³n beaten by a 2-1 marg³n, and aga³n they suspected vote forgery but ev³dence was hard to f³nd.
The federal elect³ons for F²A Nat³onal Off³ce were held on the new rules and showed large ga³ns for the Commun³sts. Short stood for Nat³onal secretary, not w³th a ser³ous chance of w³nn³ng, s³nce the ³ncumbents controlled all the Un³on resources and were under no obl³gat³on to publ³sh alternat³ve platforms, but "To keep the flag fly³ng" (he ga³ned 6673 votes to Thornton's 20,186). By now, though, both he and Or³glass were conv³nced the elect³ons were r³gged.
²n early 1945, Short won a rank-and-f³le elect³on as job delegate at Cockatoo ²sland, wh³c...